The Utah State volleyball team recently made headlines when they decided to forfeit a match against San Jose State. The reason? The opposing team had a transgender athlete. This decision has sparked a heated debate among the public, with strong opinions on both sides.
The Controversial Issue of Trans Athletes
In recent years, the participation of transgender athletes has become a contentious topic. Supporters argue for equality, while others believe that transgender athletes may have a physical advantage over cisgender athletes of the same sex. This debate has been particularly prominent in discussions around the 2024 Olympics, and has even led to boycotts of the event. Several universities in the United States have also withdrawn from sporting events this year due to the presence of transgender athletes at San Jose University.
Utah State’s Decision to Forfeit
Among the four universities that have decided to forfeit matches against San Jose State, Utah State is the most recent addition. The university released a statement earlier this week, announcing their withdrawal from the match scheduled for October 23. However, none of the universities have provided specific reasons for their decision to forfeit due to the presence of a transgender athlete on the opposing team. The University of Wyoming, another institution among the four, stated that their decision was made “after a lengthy discussion.” Utah University, on the other hand, stated that they would follow the policy of the Mountain West Conference regarding the recording of the match.
San Jose State’s Response
Michelle Smith McDonald, the senior director of media relations at San Jose State, spoke on behalf of the university. Due to the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act, she explained that the university cannot discuss the gender identity of any student. Smith McDonald expressed disappointment that San Jose State’s student-athletes, who are fully compliant with NCAA and Mountain West rules and regulations, are being denied opportunities to compete. The university remains committed to supporting its student-athletes and providing an inclusive, fair, safe, and respectful environment.
Speculation and Lawsuits
The decision of these universities to forfeit matches against San Jose State stems from speculation that originated from a conservative website. An anonymous parent at San Jose State claimed there were rumors about a transgender athlete, sparking the controversy. Currently, the NCAA is facing a lawsuit from several female athletes who argue that the participation of transgender athletes violates Title IX. Riley Gaines and Brooke Slusser are among the students involved in the lawsuit. Slusser, who joined the lawsuit in late 2023, stated that the transgender athlete personally informed her about their identity, and she refused to use their preferred pronouns. Slusser claims to have suffered physical and emotional injuries, embarrassment, humiliation, distress, and mental anguish from participating on a team with a transgender student. The NCAA has defended its commitment to Title IX and has made significant investments in women’s sports to ensure fair competition for all student-athletes.
Concerns about Privacy and LGBTQ+ Rights
The decision by Utah State to forfeit the match raises concerns about privacy rights. While the gender identity of the transgender athlete has not been officially confirmed, information has spread without their permission. Tony Hoang, the executive director of Equality California, released a statement addressing the controversy and stating that this is not just about sports but part of a coordinated attack on the LGBTQ+ community by extremist right-wing politicians. These forfeitures, according to Hoang, are harmful to all students involved.
Making History and Unresolved Debates
The debate surrounding transgender athletes participating in sports has been ongoing for several years. In 2021, Laurel Hubbard made history as the first transgender athlete to compete in the Olympics. Hubbard, a weightlifter from New Zealand, acknowledged the controversy surrounding her participation but expressed gratitude for the support she received. This historic moment further fueled the ongoing debate. It is essential to recognize that this issue is complex, with strong and mixed feelings on all sides. Transgender athletes are subject to specific rules and regulations that aim to ensure fairness and the well-being of all participants. Various sports, including cycling and BMX, have featured transgender athletes this year.
Find out more:
