A Kansas middle school teacher, Pamela Ricard, recently made headlines when she took a stand for her religious beliefs in a court case against her school district. Ricard, a math teacher at Fort Riley Middle School, was suspended after refusing to use the preferred pronouns of one of her students. She argued that her commitment to her faith was being “actively violated” and that only God assigns genders at birth. In a remarkable turn of events, Ricard emerged victorious in the case, receiving a substantial reward for her troubles.

The incident took place in 2021, sparking a national conversation about gender identity, religious freedom, and educational policy. Despite being informed of the student’s preference for an alternative first name, Ricard chose to prioritize her religious convictions. Believing that using language contrary to the student’s biological sex would go against her faith, she started referring to the student by their last name, preceded by the gendered title “miss.” Ricard believed this was a compromise that respected the student’s identity while upholding her own religious beliefs.

While there was no formal policy in place on gender pronouns at the time, Ricard was suspended under the school district’s “bullying and diversity and inclusion policies.” Feeling that her beliefs were not adequately accommodated, she requested a religious exemption multiple times. When her requests were denied, Ricard filed a federal lawsuit in 2022, claiming that her constitutional rights to free speech, religious exercise, due process, and equal protection were violated. The lawsuit also alleged that teachers were instructed to conceal student preferences by using legal names when addressing parents.

The lawsuit gained support from the Alliance Defending Freedom, a conservative Christian legal group, and Ricard’s legal team at the Kriegshauser Ney Law Group. They argued that schools should not force teachers to promote non-traditional views about gender without regard for the First Amendment or due process. Ricard’s attorney, Josh Ney, emphasized that throughout her career, she had treated all students with respect and dignity, while the school district had not shown her the same fairness.

After six months of legal proceedings, Ricard achieved a significant victory with a $95,000 settlement. The judge ruled against the school district’s attempt to compel teachers to use different names and genders without parental knowledge. Following the outcome, the district revoked its parental communications policy. Ney expressed satisfaction with the ruling, stating that it clarifies the consequences that school boards may face if they force teachers to deceive parents about their students.

The public response to Ricard’s case has been overwhelmingly supportive. Social media users praised her for standing up for her beliefs and refusing to be discredited by the school district. Many commended her courage and described her as a woman of honor and trust. As part of the settlement, Ricard’s records were cleared, and the district issued a statement confirming her standing without any disciplinary actions. Ricard retired the same year she filed the lawsuit.

We would love to hear your thoughts on this case. Do you support the teacher’s decision to stay true to her religious beliefs? Let us know your opinions, and don’t forget to share this story to hear from others!

READ MORE

• Teacher removes U.S. flag from classroom, makes kids pledge allegiance to pride flag
• Georgia teacher displays ‘Black Lives Matter’ poster in virtual classroom, parents complain